Downsizing From a Brentwood Home: Sell First or Buy First?

by Nik Shewmaker

Fence line and green space at sunset in Brentwood, Tennessee
Fence line and green space at the Brentwood library site. Photo: Dclemens1971, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Nik Shewmaker, REALTOR with Real Broker
Written by Nik Shewmaker
Top 1% REALTOR® with Real Broker. Licensed since 2008. Numbers updated November 13, 2026.

Should I sell my Brentwood home before buying a smaller one?

For most people, yes: get your current home ready and under contract first. Brentwood homes took about 11 weeks from listing to closing in October 2026, per Realtracs, and higher-priced homes take longer.

If you've been in your Brentwood home for a long time and it's more house than you need now, the hardest part usually isn't deciding to move. It's the order. Do you sell first and risk having nowhere to go, or buy first and risk carrying two homes?

There isn't one right answer, but the current Brentwood numbers make the trade-offs clearer.

What does the Brentwood market look like for someone downsizing?

About 11 weeks
List to closing
35 days on the market plus 43 days to close, October 2026.
6.6 months
Supply of homes
More choices for buyers than a year ago.
42 days
At $2.5M and up
Average days on the market for higher-priced homes.
27 days
Under $1M
Average days on the market for lower-priced homes.

Source: Realtracs Market Trends, single-family homes, Brentwood, TN. Report pulled November 13, 2026.

If you're moving from a larger home to a smaller one, there's a mismatch to plan for: the home you're selling is likely in a slower price range than the one you're buying.

The home you sell may take longer than the one you buy

Average days on the market for Brentwood homes that closed, by list price. Twelve-month average through October 2026.

Under $1M
27 days
$1M to $1.5M
32 days
$1.5M to $2.5M
37 days
$2.5M and up
42 days

Source: Realtracs Market Trends, single-family homes, Brentwood, TN. Report pulled November 13, 2026.

The home you want may go under contract faster than yours does. That's the main reason the order matters.

What are your options?

OptionHow it worksBest whenWatch out for
Sell firstSell your current home, then buy. You may rent or stay with family in between, or ask the buyer to let you stay after closing for a set time.You want to know exactly what you have to spend, and you can be flexible on timing.A possible second move, and pressure to find the next home quickly.
Buy firstBuy the new home before selling, using savings or financing against your current home.You've found the right home and can comfortably carry both for a while.Two sets of payments, taxes, and upkeep if your sale takes longer than planned.
Make your purchase contingentOffer on the new home with the sale of your current home as a condition.Your home is priced well and ready to list right away.Sellers may prefer other offers, and you'll have deadlines to meet.

Which option fits the market right now?

With supply at 6.6 months, buyers have more choices and sellers of the home you want may be more open to a contingent offer than they were a couple of years ago. At the same time, your own sale may take longer, which makes buying first riskier.

For most of the people I talk with, that points toward getting your current home ready and priced first, then shopping with a clear picture of your timeline. Your situation may be different, especially if you've already found the home you want.

How to make either path smoother

  • Get your current home ready before you shop. A home that can go live in days gives you far more options.
  • Know your numbers early. See what you might net from your sale, and talk with a lender and your tax advisor before you commit.
  • Price your home to sell on schedule. When your purchase depends on your sale, an optimistic price costs you more than usual. See how Brentwood homes are priced.
  • Build cushion into the dates. Ask about flexible closing and move-out terms on both sides.
  • Start sorting early. Deciding what comes with you takes longer than anyone expects.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to sell or buy first when downsizing?

Selling first is lower risk because you know what you have to spend and you avoid carrying two homes. Buying first can work if you can comfortably afford both for several months.

How long does it take to sell a larger home in Brentwood?

Over the 12 months through October 2026, Brentwood homes listed at $2.5 million and up averaged 42 days on the market, and homes listed from $1.5 million to $2.5 million averaged 37 days, per Realtracs. Add about six weeks from contract to closing.

Can I stay in my home after I sell it?

Sometimes. Buyers and sellers can agree to let the seller stay for a set period after closing. It has to be negotiated and put in writing as part of the contract.

Will a seller accept an offer that depends on my home selling?

Some will, and it's more likely when there are more homes on the market, as there are now. Your offer is stronger if your current home is already listed, priced well, and ready to show.

Thinking about your next move?

I'll help you map out the order and the timeline, with a pricing analysis of your current home and a look at what's available for your next one. Call or text me at (615) 585-0022, or see the homes I've sold on my Brentwood page. You can also browse Brentwood homes for sale.

Nik Shewmaker, Brentwood TN listing agent

About Nik Shewmaker

Nik Shewmaker, known as Nashville's Nik, is a Top 1% REALTOR® with Real Broker and a fifth-generation Middle Tennessean. Licensed since 2008, she has closed 235+ homes and $125M+ in Middle Tennessee since 2014.

Call or text (615) 585-0022

Market data is from Realtracs Market Trends for single-family homes in Brentwood, TN, pulled November 13, 2026. Price-range figures are grouped by list price and are twelve-month averages of monthly results. Figures change monthly. This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice.

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message