Selling an Older Brentwood Home: Update It or Sell As-Is?


Should I update my older Brentwood home before selling?
Usually, fix and freshen but don't remodel. Brentwood homes built before 2000 sold in a median of 10 days over the last year, per Realtracs, though at about 10% less per square foot than newer homes.
Nearly half the Brentwood homes that sell were built before 2000. If you own one of them, you've probably wondered whether to redo the kitchen before you sell or leave it for the next owner.
I pulled the Realtracs numbers for Brentwood homes built before 2000 and compared them with newer ones. The results are better news for older homes than most owners expect.
How do older Brentwood homes sell compared with newer ones?
Source: Realtracs Market Trends, single-family homes, Brentwood, TN. Report pulled November 13, 2026. Twelve-month average through October 2026.
Older homes sell, and they sell quickly. The trade-off shows up in price: buyers pay less per square foot and negotiate a little harder.
How much less do buyers pay for an older home?
Older Brentwood homes sell for about 10% less per square foot
Average sale price per square foot. Twelve-month average through October 2026.
Source: Realtracs Market Trends, single-family homes, Brentwood, TN. Report pulled November 13, 2026.
That gap isn't all about kitchens and baths. Newer homes also tend to be larger and have different layouts. But it gives you a sense of the ceiling: updating can close part of the gap, not all of it.
Do older homes have a harder time selling?
No. If anything, it's the reverse.
Older homes are more likely to make it to closing
Average per month. "Came off market" counts cancelled and expired listings. Twelve-month average through October 2026.
Source: Realtracs Market Trends, single-family homes, Brentwood, TN. Report pulled November 13, 2026. The newer group includes new construction, which is often relisted.
Homes built before 2000 closed far more often than they were pulled. One likely reason is price point: many older Brentwood homes sit in the range where more buyers are shopping.
Should you update before selling, or sell as-is?
Here's how I'd think it through with you.
| Usually worth doing | Decide case by case | Usually not worth it |
|---|---|---|
| Repairs a buyer's inspector will flag | Kitchen and bath refreshes (counters, fixtures, hardware) | Full kitchen or bath remodels right before selling |
| Fresh neutral paint | Flooring replacement | Additions or moving walls |
| Lighting, landscaping cleanup, deep cleaning | Roof or HVAC near the end of its life | Highly personal design choices |
The middle column depends on your home, your price range, and what your competition looks like. That's where walking through the house together matters most.
When does selling as-is make sense?
- The home needs more work than you want to manage. Some buyers want a project and will pay for the lot and location.
- Your timeline is short. A remodel can take months. Carrying costs add up while you wait.
- The next owner is likely to renovate anyway. In that case, new finishes may not come back to you in the price.
Selling as-is still means pricing for condition. See how Brentwood homes are priced and what it costs to sell.
A simple way to decide
- Get a pricing analysis both ways: as it sits today, and with the updates you're considering.
- Get real quotes for the work, with timelines.
- Compare the difference in price with the cost and the time. If the math is close, skip the project.
Frequently asked questions
Do older homes sell in Brentwood, TN?
Yes. Homes built before 2000 averaged about 33 closings a month over the 12 months through October 2026, nearly half of all Brentwood single-family closings, according to Realtracs.
How long does it take to sell an older Brentwood home?
Homes built before 2000 had a median of 10 days on the market over the last 12 months, compared with 17 days for homes built in 2000 or later.
Should I remodel my kitchen before selling?
A full remodel right before selling often costs more than it adds, and it delays your sale. Smaller refreshes such as paint, lighting, hardware, and fixtures are usually a safer use of money. The right answer depends on your home and your competition.
Can I sell my Brentwood home as-is?
Yes. Selling as-is means you won't make repairs, and the price should reflect the home's condition. Tennessee sellers still have disclosure obligations, so talk with your agent about what applies to you.
Not sure which way to go?
I'll walk through your home and show you what it could sell for as-is and updated, using Realtracs sales of similar homes. Call or text me at (615) 585-0022, or see the homes I've sold on my Brentwood page. You can also browse Brentwood homes for sale.

About Nik Shewmaker
Nik Shewmaker, known as Nashville's Nik, is a Top 1% REALTOR® with Real Broker and a fifth-generation Middle Tennessean. Licensed since 2008, she has closed 235+ homes and $125M+ in Middle Tennessee since 2014.
Call or text (615) 585-0022
Market data is from Realtracs Market Trends for single-family homes in Brentwood, TN, pulled November 13, 2026. Homes are grouped by year built, and figures are twelve-month averages of monthly results. Figures change monthly. This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice.
Categories
- All Blogs (649)
- About Nik (9)
- Brentwood Guide (51)
- Buyer Resources (43)
- Clarksville & Montgomery County Guide (28)
- Corporate Relocation (5)
- Events & Things to Do (8)
- Franklin & Williamson County Guide (52)
- Hendersonville & Gallatin Guide (84)
- Luxury & Lake Living (9)
- Market Updates (4)
- Mt. Juliet & Lebanon Guide (91)
- Murfreesboro & Smyrna Guide (46)
- Nashville Neighborhoods (56)
- Nashville Real Estate (21)
- Relocation Guide (2)
- Relocation Guides (51)
- Seller Resources (65)
Recent Posts









